Interesting topic Eva, glad you brought it up. It seems that Joe draws from a very diverse audience. Having been to both seated and stand-up shows, I have mixed feelings.
Pros and cons of each:
GA or stand-up shows - pros: you can usually get the spot near the stage that you want. You also get to be close to the artists and experience the music by being able to see the expressions and emotions as it comes out in the music. For me, being a visually detailed person and a photographer, this adds an extra dimension to the show and is what I try to capture in my photos. I think this is why DVD's of the live shows are so popular. I think you connect with the energy of the artists when you are up close and personal.
The negative side of the GA or stand-up shows: I am short, if I am not in the very front, I can't see. All of the stand up shows I have been at have allowed the drinks to flow free all evening. I can tell you that I do not enjoy having beer and other drinks slopped all over me because some drunk insists on holding their drink over their head while pumping thier arms up in the air. As a few who have attended some shows with me know, I am very protective of my camera! I am ashamed to say what would happen to the poor person who dumped their beer on my camera! Hopefully this will never be an issue, as I am not a fighter. Also it seems that at a standing show, by no choice of your own, you wind up mashed into the stage because someone who did not arrive early enough thinks that they are entitled to be at the stages edge. I think it is rude; I get in line early to get a prime spot in front of the stage and then once the show starts some think that they can just work their way to the front. At a couple of shows I was pushed forward so much that my knees were actually over the stage by several inches. It provided some unique angles for photos, but was almost too close! I could have tuned Joe's guitar for him while he was playing it!
Seated shows - pros: The audiences seem to be much better behaved or well mannered. It almost seems to me that the seated shows draw a different type of audience. You have a guaranteed seat. If you cannot get in line early it is not a problem. At a seated show, everyone has a good view of the stage. Seated shows generally allow all ages which is nice for those of us who have kids and want to see Joe.
The negative side of the seated show: You don't get the intimate experience of the artist as they experience what they are playing. You don't get to see the expressions and the emotions. This to me adds another dimension to the music. Also, the audience seems to be a bit more passive. Although you might have a good view of the stage, if your tickets are for the balcony, unless you bring binoculars, I think you miss out on a dimension of the music.
My husband and I experience shows/concerts differently. I prefer to be at the edge of the stage. He prefers to be in the back somewhere. I tell him that I experience the music and he listens to the music.
Just my observation but the stand-up shows tend to draw more of the beer drinking, screaming, chatty, rowdy type of crowd who are out for a good night of drinkin' and dancin' and the seated shows tend to draw a better behaved more (for a lack of better words) sophisticated crowd. Maybe it is related to the availability of alcohol at the shows?
I did not get to go to the Davenport show but from what Patty told me they had these awesome big monitors set up so that everyone had a close-up view of the stage. Now that would be the best of both worlds, a seated show and a closeup view that the spot at the edge of the stage provides.
In the photos of the past couple of shows that I have photographed from the side of the stag I have noticed that at the standing shows the audience is into the music. Maybe because the audience can move around more? The audience at the seated shows have a glazed over look, maybe they are just in awe?
Possible solution? Maybe to have a primarily seated show with standing behind and to the sides of the seated areas but with some big screens of monitors that allows the audience to experience the up and close feeling?
~Rhonda
"I don't think obsessions have reasons, that's why they're obsessions....National Geographic likes their pictures in focus..." Robert Kincaid