Hi,
I have several of these attenuators. The Amps I used them with were Vox mostly a AC-30 or a Marshall Bluesbreaker RI. I think every attenuator will suck the tone at a certain level. I have the THD Hotplate, Weber Mass, Marshall Powerbrake and Tubejuice. The Tubejuice is the cheapest but sounds best at low volumes. As stated before the amps live up at a certain volume level. But to me those attenuators make sense just at 1 channel amps who take the dirt out of the poweramp saturation. No point to kick a multichannel gain amp to the top. Most of these newer amps produce the sound in the preamp section and just "make it loud" in the poweramp.
My main amp is a Valvetech Hayseed 30 with Blue Bulldog speakers.
I crank the dark normal channel up and hang a rangemaster treble booster in front.
You can go from (almost) clean over a sparkly twang to insane just with the vol.pot (with single coil guitars).
It has an amazing working mastervolume. Here I don't use an attenuator anymore
but also here, in reheasalroom the sound isn't as good as on stage. Also on stage I have the
master only at 12 o'clock and this beast roars! And with its 30 tiny watts its so louuud!!!!
But it sounds amazing and eats all pedals.
Alex
...it's a musical journey
www.u2-experience.de