What kind of guitar and amp are you using? That will make a large difference in what would be a good recommendation.
And, are you playing music more similar to Brad Paisley, Joe Bonamassa, or Michael Burks?
There's so many great guitars, amps, and predals out there, nowadays! You can really get things "Tailored" to what you want.
For example, I LOVE my Timmy into a Blackfaced type amp. Even more, when using Single Coils instead of Humbuckers.
And when using my Budda amps, (EL-84), I think my RAT type pedal just smokes.
Another thing that is important, is Volume and usage. Some pedals work better with am amp whose power tubes are already cooking or at least simmering on the edge of breakup. Other pedals work better with totally clean amps.
And are you using the pedal mostly at home? Or, are you using it in a Group/Band situation? Some pedals sound great at living room levels, whrn you're playing alone, and really don't sound good in a Band Mix. While other pedals aren't really too impressive when playing by yourself. But, when in a Band Mix, they might sound incredible.
So, Styles, Usage, Amp types (What type of Tubes? Or, is it Solid State? etc.), Guitars used. All of that really makes an impact.
The good news is, there's so many great choices nowadays!
Early 80's 1957 U.S. Vintage Reissue Stratocaster (Surf Green)-Warmouth Soloist Pearly Gates Neck, Pearly Gates Bridge- Larrivee D-03 (Mahogany/ Spruce)
Carmen Ghia Head- Marshall 112 Cab W/G12H 30 or Custom 4 X 6v6 Head or Budda Twinmaster Plus Head-Traynor 212 Cab w/Eminence Texas Heats.
Mo'D-Eternity-Blues Pro- Timmy-BYOC Chorus/Vibrato- TC SCF- Korg DT 10 Pedal Tuner