19 (edited by ZeyerGTR 2011-08-23 08:43:02)

Re: copying licks

One thing i am still confused about though is wrist movement - to understand what im feeling put your hand on a flat surface and move it as far left as possible (As if youre moving up the strings) its really limited isnt it? this becomes a much bigger issue when standing up and the guitar is angled upwards and it becomes nearly impossible to reach the B or G string from the E string without being in a lot of discomfort. Is the solution to (and im hesitant of saying arm here because i know youre supposed to pick from the wrist) move your arm vertically upwards when moving to the lower strings so your wrist can keep the same position?

I see what you're saying - yes that upward (leftward) movement is limited.  But you shouldn't need to make huge wrist motions when alternate picking.   Yes, like you said you can still move your arm up and down to target different strings while the actual picking motion comes from the wrist.  See the Petrucci lesson below.

Some people (myself included, although I am away from it) tend to use a lot of finger motion to help cross strings.  I'll actually stretch out my fingers to reach the higher strings, and pinch them together to reach the lower strings.  My arm still moves, just not quite as much.  It's a subtle motion, but it lets you get away with moving your arm less.  I don't think that's a great technique in the long run (for me, anyways), because it provides too much variation from string to string.  Moving your arm up and down while keeping a consistent picking motion provides more uniformity when picking between the strings.  I'm still working on this to find where the sweet spot is....

Here's an example of picking from the arm (generally bad):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFpcVkRumEY

Eric Johnson Picking Technique:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACH5Z_YPmVg

Paul Gilbert Alternate Picking Lesson:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpJNUGHxC3M

John Petrucci Lesson (he uses a very consistent wrist motion while moving his arm up and down):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8Mr9ZQdGAM

20 (edited by Jlowther 2011-08-23 11:18:25)

Re: copying licks

ZeyerGTR wrote:

One thing i am still confused about though is wrist movement - to understand what im feeling put your hand on a flat surface and move it as far left as possible (As if youre moving up the strings) its really limited isnt it? this becomes a much bigger issue when standing up and the guitar is angled upwards and it becomes nearly impossible to reach the B or G string from the E string without being in a lot of discomfort. Is the solution to (and im hesitant of saying arm here because i know youre supposed to pick from the wrist) move your arm vertically upwards when moving to the lower strings so your wrist can keep the same position?

I see what you're saying - yes that upward (leftward) movement is limited.  But you shouldn't need to make huge wrist motions when alternate picking.   Yes, like you said you can still move your arm up and down to target different strings while the actual picking motion comes from the wrist.  See the Petrucci lesson below.

Some people (myself included, although I am away from it) tend to use a lot of finger motion to help cross strings.  I'll actually stretch out my fingers to reach the higher strings, and pinch them together to reach the lower strings.  My arm still moves, just not quite as much.  It's a subtle motion, but it lets you get away with moving your arm less.  I don't think that's a great technique in the long run (for me, anyways), because it provides too much variation from string to string.  Moving your arm up and down while keeping a consistent picking motion provides more uniformity when picking between the strings.  I'm still working on this to find where the sweet spot is....

Here's an example of picking from the arm (generally bad):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFpcVkRumEY

Eric Johnson Picking Technique:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACH5Z_YPmVg

Paul Gilbert Alternate Picking Lesson:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpJNUGHxC3M

John Petrucci Lesson (he uses a very consistent wrist motion while moving his arm up and down):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8Mr9ZQdGAM

hmm that's interesting....thanks for the links! Maybe my problem is my hand is rested too far down the bridge so im having to reach higher to the next string or something? Or maybe im just looking into it too much and it's not an exact science and like you said earlier...just playing around until it just feels right and comfortable - i do agree with you about preferring to have the same wrist motion everytime while moving the arm upwards instead of pinching fingers together to move to lower strings

and is it one of those things where if you learn the technique properly...you will be able to master the speedy licks much quicker without having to spend months on them?

Re: copying licks

I think more in terms of scales than in licks. Always has helped me. Then while I'm playing something I'll hit a part and go "Wow, that really sounded like such and such." Works for me. smile

"And in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make"

My ReverbNation page for Dees & Friends - check us out!
www.reverbnation.com/deesfriends

22 (edited by NPB_EST.1979 2011-08-23 15:19:36)

Re: copying licks

When writing songs, I try to hum or "la la la ohhh" a solo, and then match it on my guitar. It keeps my guitar knowledge limitations at bay while I sound out the solo I want in my head. Then I'm not stuck with some "routine" guitar scale or "go to" licks that I've developed over the years. haha

- Nic from Detroit... posting on JB's Forum since 6-2-2006
Ask me about my handwound Great Lakes Guitar Pickups
Since 2010, Bonamassa fans have taken advantage of my JB friend discount = my cost + shipping. cool

Re: copying licks

NPB_EST.1979 wrote:

When writing songs, I try to hum or "la la la ohhh" a solo, and then match it on my guitar. It keeps my guitar knowledge limitations at bay while I sound out the solo I want in my head. Then I'm not stuck with some "routine" guitar scale or "go to" licks that I've developed over the years. haha

Dammit... "la la la ohhh" was MY trademark lick....  lol

JBLP Gold Top #129 - redubbed "#1 in Oz"

Re: copying licks

Devan wrote:

Dammit... "la la la ohhh" was MY trademark lick....  lol

haha big_smile

- Just because i have a short attention span doesn't mean

Re: copying licks

Jlowther wrote:

that's actually a very interesting way of looking at it - taking a lick, analysing and improving

EDIT: The continuous flowing licks that Joe does often ... for example in this video at 3:08 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Yg7I5WX … re=related

are these just patterns that he's practised and he can transcribe them to any position on the fretboard?

thanks man!


If you are talking about that descending lick pattern, it is one that I also like and have been furiously practising to try and get smooth.  Check out this Youtube lesson from another TGP member, which breaks it down nicely:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2w-dVxEv … r_embedded

JBLP Gold Top #129 - redubbed "#1 in Oz"

Re: copying licks

Every guitarist steals, borrows, etc, but the good playaz know how to make it their own by changing it, sometimes just ever so slightly.  So learn many guitar solo's note for note, then chop them up into small pieces (by measure or two) and use your ears and creativeness to change it up to make it better = more you. 

What's most important while learnig solo, is to understand the chord progression, what riff was played over chord and digest it, etc, etc.  Don't learn while being brainless, look at the whole piece of work prior to solo and after solo to understand why it worked adn why you were attracted to that solo/song.

Re: copying licks

Devan wrote:
Jlowther wrote:

that's actually a very interesting way of looking at it - taking a lick, analysing and improving

EDIT: The continuous flowing licks that Joe does often ... for example in this video at 3:08 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Yg7I5WX … re=related

are these just patterns that he's practised and he can transcribe them to any position on the fretboard?

thanks man!


If you are talking about that descending lick pattern, it is one that I also like and have been furiously practising to try and get smooth.  Check out this Youtube lesson from another TGP member, which breaks it down nicely:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2w-dVxEv … r_embedded


thanks for the replies everyone! that's not quite the one i was talking about but that's still a pretty cool lick actually

28 (edited by tewker 2011-08-28 13:36:10)

Re: copying licks

I got some great advice of the justin guitar tution site.

Learn a lick, then play it a variety of ways, mix up the phrasing, mix up the order of the notes, play it backwards, that one lick can keep you going for hours just finding new interesting variations of it. Try a different end target note, always peaks my ear when Joe plays a solo live and he hits a different target note at the end of a lick. If you want to analyse it, work out what note he has hit(not only the note, but what interval, maybe note how it sounded to your ears), spend time working on playing stuff and hitting that interval at the end, work it in slow.

I wish I had the time to dedicate myself more to doing these things, slow and steady for me though smile

tewker

Re: copying licks

The JustinGuitar site is outstanding. I can't believe he offers that much high-quality stuff for free.

Re: copying licks

Hey guys, I think everyone has added something of value to this topic, however I think almost everyone has missed the point of the original question. As far as I am concerned there is no "stealing" of licks. Now before you all filet me here me out. As a child is learning to speak, they mimic the sounds they are exposed to. As their vocabulary expands they combine this new knowledge to form their own speech patterns, cadence, and accent. No one would consider this "stealing" a language. in much the same way guitarists mimic the influences they are exposed to. As time goes by all musical knowledge ( scales,modes,theory,etc..) hero worship, jamming, copying licks, are blended to form an individual's own style. So mimic, borrow, study, learn and grow.....

Guitars..'07 Custom shop 58 flametop, '11 JB studio goldtop, Nash custom aged 63 strat, Breedlove custom shop quilted Jumbo.
Amps etc: Fuchs, Blackjack 21 Head, Retro Channel RR1 Retro wreck head, Marshall 2601 Cabs loaded with eminence
Lady Luck 75 watt 12's. J.B sig Wah, J.B. FET driver, Keeley modded TS9, Boss DD3, CE2, Tu2
Pickboy 1.50 pix, EB power slinkys.

Re: copying licks

ace1962 wrote:

Hey guys, I think everyone has added something of value to this topic, however I think almost everyone has missed the point of the original question. As far as I am concerned there is no "stealing" of licks. Now before you all filet me here me out. As a child is learning to speak, they mimic the sounds they are exposed to. As their vocabulary expands they combine this new knowledge to form their own speech patterns, cadence, and accent. No one would consider this "stealing" a language. in much the same way guitarists mimic the influences they are exposed to. As time goes by all musical knowledge ( scales,modes,theory,etc..) hero worship, jamming, copying licks, are blended to form an individual's own style. So mimic, borrow, study, learn and grow.....

Agree completely

Re: copying licks

ace1962 wrote:

Hey guys, I think everyone has added something of value to this topic, however I think almost everyone has missed the point of the original question. As far as I am concerned there is no "stealing" of licks. Now before you all filet me here me out. As a child is learning to speak, they mimic the sounds they are exposed to. As their vocabulary expands they combine this new knowledge to form their own speech patterns, cadence, and accent. No one would consider this "stealing" a language. in much the same way guitarists mimic the influences they are exposed to. As time goes by all musical knowledge ( scales,modes,theory,etc..) hero worship, jamming, copying licks, are blended to form an individual's own style. So mimic, borrow, study, learn and grow.....

That is the ideal model - but I guess some folk never get to the stage where they create their own licks though, just like some people never reach the point where they write their own novel or poetry

33 (edited by Oasis.Guitar 2011-08-29 11:25:03)

Re: copying licks

Jlowther wrote:

hey guys:)

i was wondering if you guys think it's alright to steal, note for note, licks from other guitarists? where do you draw the line on this? is the key to steal from everyone and somehow make it sound your own?


I consider it more in line with the whole learning process.  Nothing hits home to a student like hearing how all of the nuts and bolts of music theory can actually be applied.  What better way to do this than through imitation.

Re: copying licks

True in any musical discipline. My schooling was in classical music but emulating the masters of the past and present greats is the way to learn. Many of the great classic pieces have cadenza sections for letting it rip in your own manner.
Rick

Free download from Vienna! http://mbsy.co/bNLR
Lots of unique videos of Joe http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cwd5vL8fXTw
Buy Joe's merchandise here. http://www.jbonamassa.com/affiliates/id … hp?id=1381

Re: copying licks

ace1962 wrote:

Hey guys, I think everyone has added something of value to this topic, however I think almost everyone has missed the point of the original question. As far as I am concerned there is no "stealing" of licks. Now before you all filet me here me out. As a child is learning to speak, they mimic the sounds they are exposed to. As their vocabulary expands they combine this new knowledge to form their own speech patterns, cadence, and accent. No one would consider this "stealing" a language. in much the same way guitarists mimic the influences they are exposed to. As time goes by all musical knowledge ( scales,modes,theory,etc..) hero worship, jamming, copying licks, are blended to form an individual's own style. So mimic, borrow, study, learn and grow.....

That's a great way to put it! Building a vocab of licks and also trying to create some as you go along