The pedal seems to need many hours to "wake up" when it's new. I found it harsh in the beginning and even changed to a 12AU7 tube. But I changed it back to 12AX7 and love the pedal. I mostly use it for Floyd stuff, and it's great. I think it's like a Muff, you have to play loooooaaaaad to get the sweet tone. But as always, even if other guitarist get good tones from pedals/amps, that doesn't automatically mean I like it when playing with my finger's that doesn't always do what I want them to.
Even semi-pro and amateur guitarists have their own tone, whatever gear used. Even I have ....
Before you sell it, try it before/after misc. pedals (both as a boost and as main distortion feeding an another pedal etc).
Go with the blues!
André