Topic: Humbucker Recommendation

I took a gamble a few months ago and bought a guitar off of ebay.  It is a 1992 Gibson Flying V 67 Reissue.  Thank God it is really a good guitar.  Very light and very resonate.  Neck plays great since I had it set up.  It is antique burst and is almost an exact replica of one that I had in the early 80's which unfortunately I sold.  Poor college kids have to eat.  I would like to keep it original but the bridge pickup is really squealing when I crank an amp or turn up the gain.  I need a good replacement pick up.  I don't want anything too hot as I feel you lose articulation and quality tone.  I am just getting back into dual humbucker guitars so I am not really up on what is out there.  I think I would like something close to an old PAF tone wise.

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

It might have 57' classics in it now since its a reissue of an older year or it might have 500T gibsons ceramic bar pickups.  V's normally have the 500 T.  Burstbuckers 2 or 3 would work good for it.  Also I think the dirty Finger sounds good too if your going to play fat chords with a good healthy chunk of distortion.  Gibson is about 135  pickup.

WCR pickups sound fantastic as do Lindy Fralins.  But those guys are expensive.  Around 150 to 200 a pickup.

Seymour Duncans antiquities sound great but their expensive as well.  Other seymours that are cheaper sound good too but I think their more modern pickups sound better then their vintage pickups in this line.  look to spend 75 to 100 a pickup 150 for antiquities.

Dimarzio sound good and offer a lot of paf pickups.  their 35th anniversery sounds killer.  75 to 100 here too.

then their is the chance takers.  GFS.  These are really cheap pickups but have a lot of tone for the money.  I use them in my favorite stratocaster and they kill.  I had tried tons of crap seymour duncan pickups and even custom shop fender and just couldn't find a sound that I liked.  I was putting a parts o caster together and bought gfs for the fact I was on a budget.  when I put them in this cheap guitar I was shocked!  These pickups sounded more Fender then anything I had tried thus far and that second pulled them out of that guitar and put them in my holyest of grail guitar Lucky the stratocaster.  Everyone who heard that guitar before agree's thats the best it ever sounded.

I've bought Tele pickups and had good success, I bought little killer pickups for strats and had great success, I've bought a vintage 59' Humbucker and put it in another strat and wouldn't you know it, it sounds awesome.  I paid $35 for the humbucker.  65 for a set for the strat, 75 for the set for another strat, 90 for the set of tele pickups.  I love them.

Now I also would like to say if you are not happy with your current humbucker you should try changing your tone cap first.  this is the worlds cheapest mod.  like .50 cent for a capasitor at radio shack???  You currently have more then likely a .022uF cap in your guitar.  If that is too bright you can go up in resistance to a .033, or a .047uf cap or even higher if needed.  A lot of people don't think this does much but it really colors the tone.  The more resistance you have the more high end Fq will be filtered.  If this doesn't work you can also switch for a 500k Pot to a 250k pot to mellow out that pickup.  You could buy all this stuff for less then $10 pot in all.  If you go paper and oil cap then thats a differnt animal altogether.  Honestly I like orange drops the best lately.  Cheap and they don't sound as dark as paper and oil.

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

Call Jim Rolph

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

Sheptone looks nice...If I change my pickups thats what I am going with.

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

I just put a pair of PG Blues (Barenuckle Pickups) in a Les Paul. Incredible sould. I love them and highly recommend them.

#275 JB LP

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

Call Hayden from Bulldog pickups mate, he will basically wind anything you like to your specs and it will cost about the same as a set of off the shelf Dimarzios  smile

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

intersesting..  http://www.flying-v.ch/pickups/pickups.html

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

Thanks for all of the great recommendations fellas.  It is amazing what is available now days as far as replacement pickups.  I remember when you had about three choices, Gibson, Dimarzio, and Seymour Duncan.

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

Bare Knuckle Mules - the best and nearest to a original '59 PAF.

Job done.

http://www.bareknucklepickups.co.uk/mai … p=the_mule

I AM NOT YOUNG ENOUGH TO KNOW EVERYTHING

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

What do you  know that link said historic 90's model gibson v's have 57' classics!  I was right!

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

wharris wrote:

Call Jim Rolph

If you gonna spend money why not make it money well spent.

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

HoosierRock wrote:

Thanks for all of the great recommendations fellas.  It is amazing what is available now days as far as replacement pickups.  I remember when you had about three choices, Gibson, Dimarzio, and Seymour Duncan.

Geez I must be old....I remember when the only replacements were Gibsons.....and there was only a humbucker, a mini-bucker and a P90.   Oh the good old days.

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

I have a bare knuckle black dog in my japanese tokai les paul copy. Sounds great, a hotter version of the mule i believe. The higher output really helps kick the amp but roll the volume back and it cleans up great.

14 (edited by NPB_EST.1979 2011-05-09 07:50:15)

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

With pickups, people reccomend what they currently have, even if they haven't tried different pickups. It's hard to experiment, and the prices of pickups aren't quite cheap enough to dabble with lots of different ones. While I am guilty of this, I usually go about my recommendations by saying "don't" get certain brands and why.


I've tried GFS Alnico II strat pickups and didn't like them. Not lively enough.
I've treid GFS strat lipstick tube pickups... not enough output and too much jangle. Looked sweet though
Tried GFS hot rails, and they were too heavy metal and didn't seem to have any mid-snarl to them.
Had a single coil Rio grande Muy grande pickup, and it over-powered all my other strat pickups.
I got rid of my Texas Specials because everyone and their grandma wants them, and I want something different.
I ended up getting some custom hand woud pickups from Smit's Pickups in Nashville. Sounds great.
I'm now winding my own strat pickups.

I had 85/81 EMG humbuckers in my 79 Explorer, and I got rid of them. They sounded amazing, but I didn't like the look  (not vintage enough). I replaced them with Rio Grande Muy Grande humbuckers and the pickups were WAY too dark. Didn't like those either. So now I'm winding my own humbuckers now.

I've had humbucker luck with Fralin's 1960 Alnico 4. Unpotted and lively... not feedback issues and just has a good feel without any of the typical buzzwords you'd associate with a great pickup. It's a "yup, this good" pickup.

My stock 70's era Gibson pickups are great and have no complaints. They don't knock your socks off but there's no way I'd take them out... they've lasted this long!

- Nic from Detroit... posting on JB's Forum since 6-2-2006
Ask me about my handwound Great Lakes Guitar Pickups
Since 2010, Bonamassa fans have taken advantage of my JB friend discount = my cost + shipping. cool

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

I think if it was me I would check out a Burstbucker 3.  My only reason for saying this is my dads traditional pro's bb3 kicks a lot of ****!

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

Bare Knuckle. Mule. Mondays. VHII. Black Dog. PG Blues.
All good...

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

DaveWammbarro wrote:

Bare Knuckle. Mule. Mondays. VHII. Black Dog. PG Blues.
All good...

I'm a fan of Lollar Imperials (standard wind) and WCR Darkbursts in LP's, Jim is a really cool guy.... Don't underestimate the role the wiring harness plays in the tone as well.

I also really like my VOS LP with Bumble Bee Caps and Burstbucker 1&2's

Re: Humbucker Recommendation

seymour duncan alnico II pros might be good for you...medium output so not too hot