Re: GLASGOW

cpt_spalding wrote:

Sorry folks, I thought the show was gash.

I've obviously been listening to the wrong albums coz I was expecting much more blues from JB last night.

Instead I had to suffer the kind of self-indulgent rock that killed the industry & made punk rock inevitable (& necessary) in the late 70's.

10 minute guitar solos with 1 minute of song in between. For sure he's a technically accomplished guitar player & he showed us that with his elongated acoustic solo.

But it was just showing off - "look what I can do with a guitar". There was no soul there. Guitar porn if you like.

An excellent technical guitarist but Stevie Ray Vaughan he ain't.

Dobber!

"Stars fall like tears from your eyes"

Re: GLASGOW

Jane..I understand you point but I don't think this guy was trying to make a point but rather to insult. Just like SILT is your favorite Joe CD, it's lower on my list. I love So Many Roads and the guitar really moves me. I'm not in love with Mountain Time like so many here...the point is we can differ in our preferences w/o attacking Joe. I don't know what this guy expected but it seems he didn't listen to the last 2 CD's. This IS Joe's house and we are guests..Cathy

Re: GLASGOW

Oh Lord, I have to post again. 

Firstly:  We don't know who he is.  I smell a set up.  Banned & back again under a different name.  I have my suspicions.

Secondly: A purist, people?  A so-called purist IMO would be a cat who plays and sings the blues and would know enough about what he's witnessing to smell the roots, the spirit, the soul, of what Joe plays and would testify to the power therein.   A purist has paid enough dues to have an opinion.  Sitting on a board or at a keyboard doesn't qualify.  the cpt is not a purist.

A purist MIGHT say, "...really good.  Don't know if I would call it true blues, but man he's good.  BTW my name is so n so..."

For example my Bonabaptism:  http://bigjeffjones.wordpress.com/2007/ … ick-bogie/   I went in there with doubts, but I came away renewed.

Thirdly:  And Joe is blusier now than ever?  Well, maybe so.  He's not a shredder.  His vocals are blues & old soul.   

bythepower
ihavespoken

Roy that's Celtic, dobber is.  Maybe Google it?

Rock On & Keep the FAITH
             It is
Blues From the Bottoms

Re: GLASGOW

I have no idea how many posts I have - probably not many, although I log in and browse most days.

I will probably be banned too now, but to ban the guy for what was an honest critical appraisal which you didn't like the content of is outrageous.

Why not ban the other guy for his use of Glaswegian slang for a penis?

Put away your petted lips!

Re: GLASGOW

Hey Michael,

Before this thread gets locked, I wanted to say thank you again for posting these videos.  Just love em.

Susan smile

"Listen to the melody cause my love is in there hiding"

Re: GLASGOW

He was a Troll but not as bad as I've seen before.  Can't wait to get home to see the vids.  I work at the Pentagon and they've block YOUTUBE.

Awestruck

Re: GLASGOW

Geez, you go away for a few hours and miss all this. roll

I have been a mod and admin on other sites for many years. I have always bent over as far backwards as I could to defend someone's right to voice an unpopular opinion. This guy was over the top imo because of some of the language that he used and because it was his first post, not because he expressed a dissenting voice. However, I would not have banned him. I would have warned him and kept a close eye on future posts.

Just my two cents worth.

RIP Iron Man

Rock On and keep the Faith

Re: GLASGOW

The funny thing is my first post about my first encounter with Joe alluded to orgasms so it was kind of close to porn!!!

Awestruck

Re: GLASGOW

To Explain the reason for banning to those that think it is harsh. This forum although moderated can only be moderated after the post is submitted. There are no checks and balances on who is allowed to post. Supplying a working e-mail is a request not a demand. You can quite simply make one up.

The mods of which I am one sometimes can't check in for long periods. During that time a lot can happen. The poster I feel made inflamatory statements that could of erupted into a firefight of words. I chose to not allow him to participate in any further dialouge.

He posted his opinion and it is there for all to see. It hasn't been deleted. Some forums moderate posts before they are even posted from new members. We hope that never has to happen here. Again I have to remind people that there are no first amendment rights on this forum.

Re: GLASGOW

Jane H. wrote:

I don't get what you mean by your suspicions jeff. banned and back again?

Since you're probably not the only one who wonders what the hell I'm talking about, here's what I suspect.  I suspect somebody we know, (not a stranger on this forum) who wouldn't dare post this sort of insulting, confrontational, pot stirring proclamation under his own username, comes on and show his/her **** just to see what happens.  In the last 2 months this is the second time this sort of nonsense has happened.

And then they vanish, banned or not.  I can't be the only one who sees this pattern.

Dissent, even be beliggerent, when we know who you are, respect is yours.  If you can't man up so to speak and you hide behind some username...I'll ignore you from now on.  Not you Jane, but in the vernacular.

The punkrocker Amplify was challenged, did the right about face in his intro and I gave him a hearty welcome and a pat on the back.  Then I laughed about Pete making me hug a punker and complained to all who would listen.  It was funny, though. lol

But it's not my forum...It's Joe's and he's grown.  You saw that post one way.  I saw it for something else.  No harm, no foul to me or by me.  Jim works for Joe.  It's his call.  not mine or anybody else who's not a mod.

If a poster wants back on, all one has to do is reinvent oneself.  Waste of precious energy.

Anyway I'm done on this thread.......Michael great vids!  I commented there on youtube for you and rated you 5 stars.

Rock On & Keep the FAITH
             It is
Blues From the Bottoms

29

Re: GLASGOW

I agree with the soulbrother bigjeff wink....he isn't a purist....the posting would have been very different. Don't take the bait....it ain't worth it. Joe know's you can't please all of the people all of the time and for every 100 new fans there will be a handful who either don't get it or quite simply choose to rock the boat, just to be different. Settle down people....nothing to see here wink

never give up, never slow down
never grow old, never ever die young

Re: GLASGOW

Jane H. wrote:

rock on, can someone please make sure there's enough toilet paper for Joe?

I'm not sure what you mean by this, but I'd be happy to.   smile

"I'm not nice to any guitar!"      lol
                 Joe Bonamassa 05-03-12

JBLP CHILD #184

31

Re: GLASGOW

Jane H.  "thanks Jeff, you, in fact are wrong,"....who...me , him or both of us? smile

never give up, never slow down
never grow old, never ever die young

32 (edited by gsj 2008-02-29 18:58:44)

Re: GLASGOW

No need for a 'sorry' Jane.

Jane H. wrote:

sorry, the other Jeff. This was not someone who posted on this forum before. The show we were discussing was their first one.

never give up, never slow down
never grow old, never ever die young

Re: GLASGOW

Michael,

Once again, I cannot thank you enough for so generously sharing the marvelous work.  Guess how we're going to spend the evening?  Yes, that's right, we will be snuggled comfortably in front of the monitor (when I'm not up dancing, that is), pretending we are far, far away, WATCHING OUR FAVORITE ARTIST OF ALL TIME WORK HIS MAGIC, once again!!!  Thank you Joe, thank you Michael, thank our mods, thank my new forum friends for all of your HARD WORK and EACH OF YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS TO MY LIFE.  I appreciate each and every one of you and cannot believe what a great time I have had here for the past two weeks.

smile  Libby  smile

I know that Joe could play one of those kid's guitars with the plastic strings and make it sound good-
Bill S.

Re: GLASGOW

bigjeffjones wrote:
Jane H. wrote:

I don't get what you mean by your suspicions jeff. banned and back again?

Since you're probably not the only one who wonders what the hell I'm talking about, here's what I suspect.  I suspect somebody we know, (not a stranger on this forum) who wouldn't dare post this sort of insulting, confrontational, pot stirring proclamation under his own username, comes on and show his/her **** just to see what happens.  In the last 2 months this is the second time this sort of nonsense has happened.

And then they vanish, banned or not.  I can't be the only one who sees this pattern.

Dissent, even be beliggerent, when we know who you are, respect is yours.  If you can't man up so to speak and you hide behind some username...I'll ignore you from now on.  Not you Jane, but in the vernacular.

The punkrocker Amplify was challenged, did the right about face in his intro and I gave him a hearty welcome and a pat on the back.  Then I laughed about Pete making me hug a punker and complained to all who would listen.  It was funny, though. lol

But it's not my forum...It's Joe's and he's grown.  You saw that post one way.  I saw it for something else.  No harm, no foul to me or by me.  Jim works for Joe.  It's his call.  not mine or anybody else who's not a mod.

If a poster wants back on, all one has to do is reinvent oneself.  Waste of precious energy.

Anyway I'm done on this thread.......Michael great vids!  I commented there on youtube for you and rated you 5 stars.

This definitely does happen. We actually know some of the people that do it. It's just childish silliness that gives us all grief for no reason. They do it to get a rise out of us, and usually it works.

When there is someone banned, it does block their IP address as well as username so it makes it a tad more difficult to start over. Not impossible, but inconvenient.

Best case scenario is that we end up being like the refs that are assigned to the Super Bowl. If you never see us, then things are going well in the game. If the refs are an issue, too many flags. In order for that to be the case, everyone has to mind their manners. All the participants on this forum have the power to control whether or not there is ever another topic that takes ANY moderation, whatsoever. It's up to you guys. Totally.

Jane, I think you miss the point. Sometimes we are so dead set on having our own opinions heard on a subject we can't actually hear what is going on.

Jim checked the forum. This post had been made. Retaliatory comments had begun. Jim had to go back to work and I was unavailable for the day, so to keep it from going completely crazy while the board was unattended for a few hours the inflammatory posters access was suspended until we had a chance to manage the situation. It might not be a lifetime and forever situation; depends on the person and the further communication. It just couldn't have been allowed to run wild with the poster stating his opinion and the faithful forum members BBQ-ing him (or her). Not good.

If we'd have closed the topic with a warning and gone away, and the OP returned to start a new thread and it got out of control.....I'm sure someone would have pointed out that we should have banned them. The only way that works is if we know we are going to be able to check back in, on a regular basis, to make sure all is OK. It's a no win.

Let's discuss Joe, the shows, the music, the trips, other artists, friendships, news, and other fun items......the things we all enjoy here. That's a lot more fun than second guessing every keystroke that is not our own, don't you think??

PC

“A friend is someone that will help you move............a TRUE friend will help you move the bodies." -- anon

Re: GLASGOW

pcornell wrote:

Let's discuss Joe, the shows, the music, the trips, other artists, friendships, news, and other fun items......the things we all enjoy here. That's a lot more fun than second guessing every keystroke that is not our own, don't you think??

PC

smile:):):)
  smile:):)
   smile:)
     smile

Not only is it more FUN Phil, but IT TAKES a heck of a lot LESS ENERGY.  I became exhausted after reading only HALF of this thread.  I don't like confrontation and it isn't the way I'd like to spend my time here.  And so, at the risk of repeating myself........

     smile
   smile:)
  smile:):)
smile:):):)


Libby wrote:

Michael,

Once again, I cannot thank you enough for so generously sharing the marvelous work.  Guess how we're going to spend the evening?  Yes, that's right, we will be snuggled comfortably in front of the monitor (when I'm not up dancing, that is), pretending we are far, far away, WATCHING OUR FAVORITE ARTIST OF ALL TIME WORK HIS MAGIC, once again!!!  Thank you Joe, thank you Michael, thank our mods, thank my new forum friends for all of your HARD WORK and EACH OF YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS TO MY LIFE.  I appreciate each and every one of you and cannot believe what a great time I have had here for the past two weeks.

smile  Libby  smile

There!  I said it again, I meant every word, and I feel better now.

smile  Libby  smile

I know that Joe could play one of those kid's guitars with the plastic strings and make it sound good-
Bill S.

Re: GLASGOW

Correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't these the people that brought us haggis??????????? Gimme meatloaf anytime!!!!!!!!! Spalding? wasn't that the kid who picked his nose and ate it in Caddyshack? OK I'm all done.

                                                                                                   The Dawg

What is success? Is it do yo' own thang, or is it to join the rest?   -Allen Toussaint