Jethro Tull - A Passion Play (1973 - 2014 remix; 2024 reissue)
Not sure what is going on here, but this is the 40th Anniversary box-set of Steven Wilson's skilled remix of Tull's 1973 album, re-issued 10 years after, though fortunately NOT re-labelled as 50th Anniversary since it contains no changes.
So, A Passion Play, not universally acknowledged as a master-work in Jethro Tull's canon; it's didn't chart well in the UK (though was a #1 in the US) has always been a bit divisive among fans. Reading the book notes though, it's easy to see why. Following an aborted working session at the acclaimed Chateau d'Herouville (France), Jethro Tull promptly returned to the UK (despite the heavy income tax situation of the day) to commence recording. However, Anderson decided to ditch all the work that had been done in France and to start over, on completely new songs. A bold step, especially with deadlines looming, but the band managed; this was the first time the band had recorded successive albums with the line-up unchanged, so maybe the chemistry was working.
However; this "rush" shows through; while the musicianship across the board is outstanding, there's signs that maybe they were overcooking things; arrangements were very complex with intricate changes throughout. While A Passion Play wasn't strictly a "concept album" as it's released predecessor Thick As A Brick, it came over a very involved "prog" album. The theme it seems, is somebody's journey through purgatories after finding themselves after a road traffic accident; though the songs are very much separate tracks. To my ear though, none have an immediate hook. It didn't help the band, or album that it was debuted here in a complete, live run-through, which also confounded previously loyal critics.
That said, the 2nd disc of this set, the Chateau d'Herouville sessions has Steven Wilson breathe his magic over the tapes that Anderson brought back from France of the aborted original [untitled] album, though from Wilson's own account, he did very little aside from take out some later trimmings and drop a couple of takes of Anderson's flirtings with soprano sax. From these shelved recordings, Skating Away On The Thin Ice of A New Day and Only Solitaire appearing on the Warchild sessions, and the former was a live favourite though very little else was heard until an 11 minute section entitled Chateau D'Isaster appeared on a 20th anniversary Jethro Tull compilation and the later Nightcap compilation.
For me, despite it's unfinished status, this is Jethro Tull in full-flight. Anderson's writing/singing as ever is to the fore, but while everyone else is in fine fettle (a miracle if you read the booklet), it's John Evans who really shines through on keyboards; this is his golden moment. From the pictures of the tape boxes, the 60 minutes of music is labelled up to "Side 3", so presumably this could have been a double album from Jethro Tull, pending the record label having them trim it down, an unlikely scenario given the crest of the wave they were riding at that time.
So, if there's any criticism, A Passion Play needed more time to be trimmed of it's excesses and Jethro Tull wasn't punching over it's weight so much as punching over it's audience's head. It's still a "hard" album to listen to, but casually; you really need to sit and absorb it. As for the French sessions, well Anderson did leap-frog this work but fortunately a lot did resurface in the soon to appear Warchild.
When life gives you lemons; don't make lemonade.
Give back the lemons. Why were the lemons free? What's wrong with the lemons?
Do Not trust the lemons...