1 (edited by greg_1006 2009-05-07 04:16:24)

Topic: Please Help amp decision

I'm in the market for a new amp, looking to mix it up with dual amp setup. Marshall + dumble. For the marshall style I'm either thinking vintage modern or an orange of some kind (rockerverb 100?). I want to make sure it mixes well with an el34 dumble though which will either be the ceriatone or the carol ann od2. Depending on where my funds are at the time. I'm getting the marshall style amp first.

I play all styles of music. So vintage modern or orange(el34)? which will blend better with a dumble ?(el34 or 6l6 i'm open to suggestions)

Which of these two comes closest to the jubilee?

Any experience with Orange amps Joe?

Re: Please Help amp decision

Welcome to the forum Greg!  Be warned, this place is a very expensive place to hang around lol .  Obviously if you have the funds the Carol-Ann would be a great choice.  Alan makes some killer amps no doubt.  I have a Ceriatone HRM100 that absolutely kills and is far less than some other Dumble clones.  As for the Marshall thing, you can also go Ceriatone but I am a believer in what George is doing over there at Metropoulous amps.  He makes some DEADLY accurate Marshall clones.  All in all you could probably spend less than $3000 to more than get you where you want to be.  Of course there are much cheaper alternatives, but when you started by mentioning Carol Ann I assume you enjoy the finer things in life? wink  Ceriatone is the only company that offers a Jubilee clone that I know of at this current time.  Alex (aka Stratvari) owns both and actually seems to prefer his clone.  I'm going to be posting some more clips of my rig soon, maybe with the Dailey as well which is a great sounding amp as well.  Good luck, amp shopping is so much fun!

'67 and '74 Fender Twin Reverbs, '74 Marshall 1987 lead mkII, Metro Superlead 100. Pedals from TC Electronic, Ibanez, Dunlop, BK Butler, Electro-Harmonix, Fulltone, Maestro/Gibson, Loopmaster switching, VoodooLab, Boss. Gibson and Fender guitars, Dimarzio pickups.

Re: Please Help amp decision

Hi and welcome the bonabuddy forum.
Stratpaulguy has said everything. Especially with the expensive thing...I can subline that.
The Marshallsound is the base and should really sound perfect to you
that basicly you wouldn't need second amp. Everythin else is bonus.
Joe said if he would play only his Carol-ann all night long then the people
would want their money back. lol
Means the basic sound has to be very good. And the Dumble stuff is the only
for the blending.

@Justin: I watched your clip again and it itches me to order a HRM....

/Alex

...it's a musical journey
www.u2-experience.de

Re: Please Help amp decision

If time allows, I'll be able to give a proper demo especially of the HRM.  It really is a sweet amp.  Alex, if you add a OTS to your arsenal you could run a 4 amp rig with the Ceratione 2550, Marshall 2555, Budda SD30, and the OTS.  YIKES.

'67 and '74 Fender Twin Reverbs, '74 Marshall 1987 lead mkII, Metro Superlead 100. Pedals from TC Electronic, Ibanez, Dunlop, BK Butler, Electro-Harmonix, Fulltone, Maestro/Gibson, Loopmaster switching, VoodooLab, Boss. Gibson and Fender guitars, Dimarzio pickups.

Re: Please Help amp decision

thanks for the replies. Yeah, I really liked that demo you did with the hrm + Dsl. That's pretty much what sold me on that amp. I still like the Carol Ann a lot and the tone that Joe gets with his jubilee and od2 el34 on stop is amazing. I want something similar but  to achieve it with perhaps a different Marshall style amp. That's why I asked for opinions on the rockerverb 100 and the vintage modern. I've got a fair bit of gear experience just not much with Marshall and none with Dumble style amps. I've owned and played through a couple of new Marshall amps(dsl50, avt100, ..) but never through a jcm800 of a jubilee or anything .

Re: Please Help amp decision

Could I jump in here a bit? I am in exactly the same boat.

I am aiming at the dual amp setup and I have my "Marshall" side of it with a modded Orange Rockerverb (running with KT88s).

I am stuck between the Ceriatone 2550 (Jub clone as everyone knows) or the Ceriatone OTS (Dumble-esque) - any ideas?

Or other suggestions (I will keep coming back to this thread).

I am in the UK and the 2550 works out at around £650, while the OTS comes in at around £950 (so you can see what budget I am aiming at). Would the 2550 be too close to the Orange do you think?

Re: Please Help amp decision

It all depends on what Joe type sound you are after.  He has 3 primary tones: 1) Cleaner Dumble+chorus/reverb w/Marshall for chords and articulate leads, 2)  Gainier Dumble/Marshall with more reverb and mids for the solo sound, and 3) the "Double Marshall" sound that he seems to have always had in his rig.  The plexi marshall is much cleaner and warmer sounding, the Jubilee is providing the gain/saturation.  My personal fav is the Cleaner Dumble +chorus/reverb/Marshall sound because you can always add more gain with pedals and change the sound to get more of the Marshall thing.  To my ears when you add the Dumble sound in the mix it gets more of that Eric Johnson/Robben Ford smooth liquid sound and when you have 2 Marshall style amps its more of that dry, crunchy, old school rock type tone that is not as polite.  You just have to decide what sound you are after! big_smile

'67 and '74 Fender Twin Reverbs, '74 Marshall 1987 lead mkII, Metro Superlead 100. Pedals from TC Electronic, Ibanez, Dunlop, BK Butler, Electro-Harmonix, Fulltone, Maestro/Gibson, Loopmaster switching, VoodooLab, Boss. Gibson and Fender guitars, Dimarzio pickups.

Re: Please Help amp decision

Not as Polite - I like that lol.  We call that "Rude" in my house.  Thats the term me and my dad call it when I play my Emplexador (by the way thanks for the comments in the other thread).

Re: Please Help amp decision

No problem Ben!  You deserve it for all the time/effort/money you put into that monstrosity.  I probably watch your demo once a day for fun, it just sounds killer.  I really dig the Emplexador, but that may be because for now I'm itching for a true dedicated plexi amp.  It's "rude" but also very warm and thick.  I am considering a 1987 or JTM45 Metro build next to match up with my Dailey.  Again, thanks a lot for the kind words everyone.

          -Justin

'67 and '74 Fender Twin Reverbs, '74 Marshall 1987 lead mkII, Metro Superlead 100. Pedals from TC Electronic, Ibanez, Dunlop, BK Butler, Electro-Harmonix, Fulltone, Maestro/Gibson, Loopmaster switching, VoodooLab, Boss. Gibson and Fender guitars, Dimarzio pickups.

Re: Please Help amp decision

Marshall Vintage Modern will get you the Marshall end of it..it's a really great amp!

This is my lead-sound using a tubescreamer..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZEcmsKI … annel_page

GR. and good luck!

PJ

Re: Please Help amp decision

not bad, what are your amp settings?

Re: Please Help amp decision

greg_1006 wrote:

not bad, what are your amp settings?

Marshall 2266 Vintage Modern + Orange 2x12 cabinet (V30's)

Master: ofcourse the higher the better, but mine was quiet low..
Reverb: 3 'o clock
Presence: 3 '0 clock

B: noon
M: full
T: noon

Low dynamic range with Mid-boost off
Body: about 1 'o clock
Detail: about 2 'o clock

This is a clean sound -> Tubescreamer: Volume full, Tone almost off, Gain full.

Gr; PJ

13 (edited by Carol-Ann_Amps 2009-05-14 04:39:44)

Re: Please Help amp decision

Stratovari wrote:

Hi and welcome the bonabuddy forum.
Stratpaulguy has said everything. Especially with the expensive thing...I can subline that.
The Marshallsound is the base and should really sound perfect to you
that basicly you wouldn't need second amp. Everythin else is bonus.
Joe said if he would play only his Carol-ann all night long then the people
would want their money back. lol
Means the basic sound has to be very good. And the Dumble stuff is the only
for the blending.

@Justin: I watched your clip again and it itches me to order a HRM....

/Alex

This statement has been mis-quoted and thrown around on several forums saying Joe was ripping on CA etc etc . I highly doubt for one second Joe would rip the amp or me in any way, he just isn't like that. End of story. Also, if he didn't like them, they wouldn't be in one rig let alone all three.

Joe said nothing wrong, I know exactly what he meant. It's technically correct. Let me explain.....

The CA JB-100s that Joe use are set up as a mid-range amp in his rig. They are a two-channel amp and can be set however you want. Joe overdrives the clean channel and has the mid boost at 850Hz on all the time. Massive mid range !! It is being used as mid range amp to be blended with the Jubilee, which is set on the lead channel and fills the high and low end. With the settings he uses, it's not supposed to be run on it's own....THAT WAS THE POINT HE WAS MAKING !!! I designed and tested it to be used with a 2555 Jubilee.
That said the JB-100 is a very versatile amp and doesn't need to be set up like this, most folk using just one amp certainly wouldn't. If Joe was only using that amp all night he certainly wouldn't set it up like this either.  Get my point ?

I will end by saying these little digs, twists, misquotes and sarcastically placed smileys on forums by some folks do nothing but hurt someone who works very very hard to get the best products he can out there.

Re: Please Help amp decision

Well said Alan and I agree 100%.  I don't really think anyone believes that a Carol-Ann is anything but a fantastic handbuilt tone machine.  However, the only people who have heard a great deal about them are probably either TGP-ers or huge Joe Bonamassa fans.  So for someone to take that as Joe was putting them down is a 'tard.  For those who understand Joe's sound (Stratovari included) know this and I don't think he meant anything by it.  I believe he was directly quoting Joe's Guitar Center session and I really think Joe was trying to make the same point you were Alan.  I set my Ceriatone the same way, pretty much all midrange with no lows or highs.  It's not a do it all setup like my Ceriatone and CERTAINLY your very well built Carol-Ann can accomplish.  I believe I have actually seen Joe use 2 Carol-Ann's at one point so it's ludicrous for anyone to think that he doesn't LOVE them.  He can play anything in the world and chooses a Carol-Ann.  I would love one but at my budget I chose to go Ceriatone.  If anyone should be offended it would be Robben Ford!  He's probably thinking, "WTF people want their money back because of my tone...<commits suicide>"  BTW Alex (Stratovari) is a super nice dude. Sometimes attitudes, moods, and meaning are lost in text...Keep up the hard work Alan!  Screw the naysayers on the other forums! mad <----not sarcastic smiley

         -Justin

'67 and '74 Fender Twin Reverbs, '74 Marshall 1987 lead mkII, Metro Superlead 100. Pedals from TC Electronic, Ibanez, Dunlop, BK Butler, Electro-Harmonix, Fulltone, Maestro/Gibson, Loopmaster switching, VoodooLab, Boss. Gibson and Fender guitars, Dimarzio pickups.

Re: Please Help amp decision

Carol-Ann_Amps wrote:

The CA JB-100s that Joe use are set up as a mid-range amp in his rig. They are a two-channel amp and can be set however you want. Joe overdrives the clean channel and has the mid boost at 850Hz on all the time. Massive mid range !! It is being used as mid range amp to be blended with the Jubilee, which is set on the lead channel and fills the high and low end. With the settings he uses, it's not supposed to be run on it's own....THAT WAS THE POINT HE WAS MAKING !!!

Oh well, misunderstood...
Alan, on nothing else I was referring. I understand Joes setup well and what frequencies each amp is sublining.
The CA is setted on a totally midrange. And on this settings it probably too middy to play it alone..
With the blending of the Jubilee its phenomenal of course.
And yes - for somebody who hasn't seen the guitar center video this point get lost in my reply. Mea culpa! 
Let me say that I love the CA amps. I never heard such complex and sweet mids on any other amp.
So let me close that in no way there was any offense meant.

Justin, thanks for backing me up here.

/Alex

...it's a musical journey
www.u2-experience.de

16 (edited by Carol-Ann_Amps 2009-05-14 14:40:07)

Re: Please Help amp decision

Stratovari wrote:
Carol-Ann_Amps wrote:

The CA JB-100s that Joe use are set up as a mid-range amp in his rig. They are a two-channel amp and can be set however you want. Joe overdrives the clean channel and has the mid boost at 850Hz on all the time. Massive mid range !! It is being used as mid range amp to be blended with the Jubilee, which is set on the lead channel and fills the high and low end. With the settings he uses, it's not supposed to be run on it's own....THAT WAS THE POINT HE WAS MAKING !!!

Oh well, misunderstood...
Alan, on nothing else I was referring. I understand Joes setup well and what frequencies each amp is sublining.
The CA is setted on a totally midrange. And on this settings it probably too middy to play it alone..
With the blending of the Jubilee its phenomenal of course.
And yes - for somebody who hasn't seen the guitar center video this point get lost in my reply. Mea culpa! 
Let me say that I love the CA amps. I never heard such complex and sweet mids on any other amp.
So let me close that in no way there was any offense meant.

Justin, thanks for backing me up here.

/Alex

Thanks guys, appreciate the clarification. I tend to get a little over-sensitive as I get a lot of people trying to pull me down or prove me wrong for some reason.

I actually listened to that clip again today and whats quite funny to me is that the red JB-100 was heavily designed with a lot of input from Eric Johnson as well as Joe. I spent two days with Eric tweaking an amp to a certain specification and the same preamp was used in that amp. I love that whenever Joe demos that particular amp, I always hear some of Erics influence to. Joe is an amazing player that has his own distinctive tone and feel, but he can capture the style and feel of other players really when he wants to for the purposes of demoing things.

The other point I took from the video was where he talks about the Jubilee. Most folk think the LED/Diode clipping is the key to the Jubilees tone. Yes it certainly is an easy and effective way of creating assymetrical clipping without using several tube gain stages and works reallywell, but the key to that amp is in it's power amp section. The 100W Jubilee has the least amount of negative feedback and power amp damping of virtually any 100W Marshall. What that means is it has very emphasised highs and lows. The low end is not very tight at all at mostvolume settings and wouldn't work in a lot of situations, but with Joe driving it into power tube OD, it tends to tighten it up a little more.  Most people would never play a Jub at the level he does and would be possibly dissapointed with the low volume results if they were trying to capture Joes tone, they sound somewhat thin and fizzy and the low end is woofy. Grind those babies up and they take on a whole different persona. This is also probably why Joe doesn't think the 50W Jub sounds the same. At bedroom volumes they actually do, but once they are wound up they are like two totally different amps with very different frequency responses.
The CA JB-100 has 3 times the amount of power amp feedback, with a lot more damping than the Jub, which smooths out and flattens the entire amp and it tends to have a less extended low end, but it's much tighter at any volume. To sit between the Jub, it can't afford to have much of an extended low end. It would bcome very muddy.

The last thing that should be noted is the use of barriers in front of the speaker cabinets. This REALLY helps tighten the low end up a lot, frequencies in the bass ranges can take several feet to fully form. These really low frequencies are reflected a lot by the plexiglass shields before they are fully formed, in a way creating a negative feedback loop with the sound waves themselves. This has a huge effect on the perceived low end and really tightens it right up. If Joe removed these (apart from it being bloody loud) the low end would take on a totally different feel and his rig would sound completely different. The distance that the shields are from the cabinets would also change the frequency response of the rig. The closer it is, the more the low end will be tightened.

So for anyone who is trying to replicate Joes rig, all the pieces have to be there and being run at the same levels or else your result will be very very different.

17 (edited by NPB_EST.1979 2009-05-14 15:24:08)

Re: Please Help amp decision

I cannot believe there is an amp that can do EVERYTHING, I don't need one to. But all I need is one amp on stage. Joe is the kind of person that likes to EQ different amps to work in synergy. He has always been like this since I started watching him in 2003.

When I go to buy an amp, I like it to have a strong clean channel, and enough dirt where I wouldn't need a pedal. Anything additional is icing on the cake like reverb or any other effects (major plus). I think amps can go overboard very quickly with channels, features, knobs, effects, etc.

- Nic from Detroit... posting on JB's Forum since 6-2-2006
Ask me about my handwound Great Lakes Guitar Pickups
Since 2010, Bonamassa fans have taken advantage of my JB friend discount = my cost + shipping. cool

Re: Please Help amp decision

BRAVO! Thanks Alan for giving us even more details about Joe's rig.  There is some really good info in there that explains a lot about how Joe gets his sound!  I also find it interesting that Eric Johnson played a hand in how the Red Carol-Ann was voiced...
I know Eric is probably the most famous tone hound out there and he has amazing tone today, but I have been REALLY waiting for him to add another Dumble-type amp back in to his lineup.  I think his tone was the BEST when he had his Dual Twin, SSS, and 100 watt Marshalls all blasting.  I see all these sites where they claim Eric uses this or that pedal/amp/guitar but he always has the same rig everytime live...a couple Marshalls and Fenders.  I would love to see EJ use something more modern and updated which the CA definately fits that refined Dumble/Marshall bill.  And I also find it funny how Joe still seems to be one of the only guys shielding their amps.  EJ always complains that the bigger amps are way better sounding but he has to comprimise because of the extreme volumes.  Derek Trucks used them last I saw him...sounded great!  Anyways, take the critisim for what it is.  Anyone who is knocking a Carol-Ann is probably because they can't afford one!  This ain't TGP, we're all fans here!  We're on the same side! wink Thanks again for sharing how Joe uses your amp in his rig.  More or less that is the sound I was after building my 2 amp rig (can't justify the 4 roll ).

And to Alex, I got your back man.  Not that there was any need to defend because it was all miscommunication, but regardless... have a nice day everyone!

      -Justin

'67 and '74 Fender Twin Reverbs, '74 Marshall 1987 lead mkII, Metro Superlead 100. Pedals from TC Electronic, Ibanez, Dunlop, BK Butler, Electro-Harmonix, Fulltone, Maestro/Gibson, Loopmaster switching, VoodooLab, Boss. Gibson and Fender guitars, Dimarzio pickups.